Hundreds of protesters gathered outside the residence of Minnesota’s governor on Friday to protest lockdown.
The New York Times April 18, 2020
That’s the kind of story the news likes to tell. It’s a great story because it’s unusual and disturbing at the same time.
Unusual because we should all have understood by now what this virus is all about and why and how we should help to contain its spread. Disturbing, because there are people who see it differently, express it militantly and thus again become a danger to everyone.
Somewhere in the USA, where not only the brightest lights live, hundreds (and on the pictures it looks more like hundred than hundreds) of the most stupid apes have gathered, waving blue-white-red flags and doing hullabaloo. They protest that the lockdown will be lifted. They demand their normal life back.
This is stupid for two obvious reasons.
1. as long as a larger part of society is afraid of a contagious disease, which can best be protected from by renouncing normal life, there will be no normal life.
2. it is a stupid idea to form a group with 100 others at times when a contagious virus is circulating.
In the sense of the opponents of the lockdown, an information campaign would make more sense, which explains to the people that their worries are completely unfounded because… And exactly this “because” is what is lacking. Because there are no good arguments. (The “argument” of the lockdown plunges many people into a shitty situation is not an argument, it is an observation).
Putting yourself in a group of 100 people at the moment is also pretty stupid, because it increases the risk of getting infected with the virus (even if you don’t believe in it). But this demonstration is unlikely to result in its participants becoming infected. The larger the group of people, the more likely they are to be infected, but for this relatively small group, the probability is not too high.
So most likely these idiots will not be infected, but they will probably use this as a way to “prove” how exaggerated the fear is. (Strictly speaking, they are just proving how bad their understanding of probability is, but that is nothing unusual, because humans in general are terribly bad at grasping probabilities intuitively (see Kahneman, “Thinking, Fast and Slow”).
The danger is high, however, that they will give others stupid ideas.
The perfidious thing about the story of the events, like the demonstration of the stupid monkeys in Minnesota, is that telling the story leads to many more people getting similarly stupid ideas. If 1000 times 100 people meet and wave flags, then we will almost certainly have a Super Spreader Event. That will actually have an impact.
So the only really scary element in the story of the demonstration of the stupid monkeys is the fact that we tell it to each other – and spread it by telling it.
In fact, the story is like the Corona virus itself. Anyone who tells the story transmits the virus. Most people don’t get sick.If someone gets sick, one symptom of the illness is that they go out into the street, form groups with others, wave flags and shout “Freedom!
By the way, this is the same with all stories. (The symptoms of the respective illness are very different and in most cases completely harmless).
Stories are viruses.
5 Replies to “STORIES ARE VIRUSES”
Hi Florian ! Stories can indeed like virus spread and it sometimes takes place in a really bad way, See the exemple that follows, here in Brazil it is beeing like a Plague as well for a certain kind of our local apes.
Take care #stayhome
There are people that are more prone to get infected by stories than others. Or is it, that we (the #stayhome-people) just get infected by an other story? I personally think that I did not get infected by the story. Why do I think that? Because I actually don’t have an opinion. I do not know if it makes sense to stay at home. Nevertheless I do stay at home. I understand enough to see why it could make sense. And I do trust certain people that have better information and access to wiser opinions. So is having an opinion a symptom of getting infected by a story?
I Think that having a opinion is as you said is a question of having acess to people who has wiser and cientific facts that foreground its informations. Maybe there are people that doesn’t trust this wiser information and prefer to think the other way. Providing good information and strategies of this being acquired well and with confidence, I think is the greatest challenge of our times. Cheers !
So do you think, the problem that people come up with nonsensical opinions is because there is not enough good information?
not just not enough good information and particulary in Brazil people has this nonsensical opinions because we have a very concentrated media. But the worst I think it is an unequal educational system, a way that keeps social inequality.
See more in this article about media concentraition in Brazil.
“When comparing our risk indicators for plurality in the media with those of ten other countries analyzed by the Media Ownership Monitor, Brazil presents the most serious scenario of risks to pluralism. The absence of an efficient legal framework that combats monopolization and oligopolization and promotes the plurality of voices in Brazilian communication is a gap that has serious consequences for the circulation of ideas, diversity and democracy.”
Saudações from Brazil !
Comments are closed.